The Alberta Court of Appeal, for reasons Shaun argued in the Court of Queen's Bench, found a competing lien claim invalid.
The transfer of farm property to by father to sons (Shaun’s client) was confirmed on appeal and the plaintiff's allegations of civil conspiracy were likewise dismissed. The Plaintiff's application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada was dismissed.
Shaun successfully had builder's liens struck and a certificate of lis pendens discharged from the landlord's title. The liens were found to have been wrongly filed against the wrong title.